OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts

The quick rule of thumb

PARTS

OEM

AFTERMARKET

Bumpers, grilles or mirrors with radar, cameras or parking sensors

✓

✗

Structural parts and bumper reinforcements

✓

✗

Leased car or a car under three to five years old

✓

✗

Cosmetic part on an older car, paying out of pocket (aftermarket or a quality used OEM part can save money)

✓

✓

OEM parts are made by or for your car's manufacturer, and they're the safest choice for anything near a safety sensor, anything structural, and newer or leased cars. Aftermarket parts are made by other companies and cost less. They can be a reasonable choice for cosmetic parts on older cars, but fit and quality vary.

In California, every part on a body shop estimate must be identified as OEM or aftermarket, so you can always see what you're getting.

EXPLAINED

What are OEM, aftermarket and used parts?

The difference is who made the part and whether it's new.

OEM (original equipment manufacturer). Made by your car's manufacturer or its supplier, to the same specifications as the parts your car was built with.

Aftermarket (non-OEM). New parts made by other companies to fit your car, usually for less. Some are certified by CAPA (the Certified Automotive Parts Association), an independent group that tests aftermarket parts against the originals; many aren't.

Used (recycled or salvage). Genuine OEM parts taken from another vehicle. Good used parts can save money on older cars, but condition and history vary.

Rebuilt or reconditioned. Used parts that have been repaired, such as a straightened bumper or refinished wheel.

OEM

When do OEM parts matter most?

OEM matters most when a part affects safety systems, structure, or how the car looks and fits.

Safety sensors (ADAS). Most newer cars have radar, cameras and parking sensors behind bumpers, grilles, mirrors and windshields. A part that's slightly thicker, a different material, or shaped differently can block or misaim a sensor. Ford's May 2026 repair position statement, for example, rejects aftermarket, recycled or reconditioned ADAS sensors and warns that aftermarket or recycled bumper covers can interfere with radar signals.

Calibration after repairs. Ford also requires sensor calibration after any ADAS-related repair, even when no warning light is on. Other automakers have similar rules.

Fit and finish. OEM panels line up with factory gaps and body lines. Aftermarket panels sometimes need extra work to fit.

eases and newer cars. Many lease agreements require OEM parts at turn-in, and factory-correct repairs protect resale value.

Structural and crash parts. Bumper reinforcements, crash absorbers and anything that manages crash energy should match the original exactly.

Source: Ford Collision Position Statement, "ADAS Integrity and Repair Technical Imperatives," May 1, 2026 (I-CAR)

PARTS

When can aftermarket or used parts make sense?

Non-OEM parts can be a smart way to save money when the part is cosmetic, the car is older, and there are no sensors involved.

Older cars without driver-assist sensors, where the repair cost matters more than factory originality.

Cosmetic parts like some trim pieces, mirror covers or lights, where fit is easy to check.

Discontinued parts for classic or older cars, where a quality used OEM part may be the best option available.

Paying out of pocket on a budget, when you'd rather fix the car well for less than wait or pay for new OEM.

If you go non-OEM, ask whether the part is CAPA-certified and how the shop will check its fit before painting.

COMPARISONS

OEM vs. aftermarket vs. used parts, side by side

OEM (new)

Made by

Your car's manufacturer or its supplier

COst

Highest

Fit

Matches factory

SAfety-sensors

Built for them

QUality check

Manufacturer standards

Best for

Newer, leased and sensor-equipped cars

Aftermarket (new)

Made by

Another company

COst

Lower

Fit

Varies; may need adjusting

SAfety-sensors

May interfere

QUality check

CAPA certification on some parts

Best for

Cosmetic parts on older cars

Used OEM

Made by

Your car's manufacturer, from another vehicle

COst

Usually lowest

Fit

Factory fit if undamaged

SAfety-sensors

Varies with condition

QUality check

Inspection by the shop

Best for

Older or discontinued models

CALIFORNIA

What are your parts rights in California?

California requires that you're told which parts are used, and it limits when an insurer can require aftermarket parts.

Every part on the estimate must be labeled. Body shop estimates must say whether each crash part is OEM or non-OEM aftermarket, or used, rebuilt or reconditioned. Vague labels like "like kind and quality" or "Opt-OE" don't count.

Insurers can require aftermarket parts only under strict conditions. The parts must be at least equal to OEM in kind, quality, safety, fit and performance, and the insurer must warrant that in writing on the estimate.

The insurer pays to make them fit. If an aftermarket part needs modifications to work, the insurer that specified it pays for them.

Parts must be marked. Replacement crash parts need permanent markings that identify the manufacturer.

When you pay out of pocket, you choose. You decide between OEM, aftermarket or used parts with your shop.

Sources: California Department of Insurance notice on CCR §2695.8(g) · Repairer Driven News on California BAR estimate rules

OEM POLICY

How Dentco handles parts

We tell you exactly what goes on your car, and we recommend OEM wherever safety, fit or value depends on it.

Every part is listed in writing as OEM, aftermarket or used, before we start.

OEM for sensors, structure and newer cars. We use OEM parts by default.

Money-saving options when they make sense. On older cars, we'll help you find a quality used OEM part. One customer restoring a 1991 Mercedes saved money when Brian helped source a fender outside the dealer.

Paying out of pocket? You decide. We'll show you the price of each option side by side.

Not in any insurer's direct repair program, so no network parts rules decide what goes on your car.

Lifetime warranty on paint and workmanship.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Quick answers about OEM and aftermarket parts and how DentCo works.

What's the difference between OEM and aftermarket parts?

OEM parts are made by or for your car's manufacturer to factory specifications. Aftermarket parts are made by other companies to fit your car and usually cost less, but fit and quality vary.

Are aftermarket body parts safe?

Some are fine for cosmetic use, but parts near safety sensors or that absorb crash energy should be OEM. Several automakers now reject aftermarket parts around driver-assist sensors.

Can my insurance company make me use aftermarket parts?

In California, only under strict conditions. The parts must be at least equal to OEM in kind, quality, safety, fit and performance, the insurer must warrant that in writing, and it must pay for any modifications needed to make them fit.

How do I know what parts a shop is using?

Ask for a written estimate. California requires each crash part to be identified as OEM, aftermarket, used, rebuilt or reconditioned.

What does CAPA-certified mean?

CAPA, the Certified Automotive Parts Association, is an independent group that tests aftermarket parts against the originals. A CAPA-certified part has passed its testing; uncertified parts haven't been independently checked.

Do aftermarket parts affect resale value?

They can. Poor fit or uneven gaps are easy for buyers to spot, and lease companies often require OEM parts at turn-in.

Does Dentco use OEM parts?

Yes, wherever safety, fit or value depends on it, and we list every part in writing. If you're paying out of pocket, we'll show you OEM, aftermarket and used options so you can choose.

Know exactly what goes on your car.

Stop by our Laguna Hills shop during business hours. No appointment needed, and you will leave with a written price and a clear timeline.

This page is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Automaker repair requirements and insurance practices vary; check your policy and your vehicle's repair information.

Call (949) 997-3211